User avatar

Charlie II

The Grammar Nazi fled across the forum and the Punslinger followed...

  • Novel / Chapter » Fantasy, Action / Adventure Re: The Charm of Deception, Prologue

    Heya Shadow! I like reading prologues like this because it's actually quite interesting. Rather than having a short chronology of the fantasy world you've created, it's actually about characters and ...

    Jun 29, 2013
  • Novel / Chapter » Realistic, Narrative Re: Un-fufilling Realizations

    Hey cj2344! First, let me say that this is one of the best shorts that I've read on YWS for some time. You have a clear command of language and ...

    Jun 2, 2013
  • Novel / Chapter » Action / Adventure, Narrative Re: Pokemon Ultimate Evolution: Episode 5, The Ralts Girl.

    Hey dark! I quite enjoyed the Pokémon series when I used to watch it on TV so I thought I'd check your piece out. Imagine my surprise when I find ...

    Jun 1, 2013
  • Lyrics » Lyrical, General Re: Illiterate Mimes

    Hey Sololol! It's always strange reviewing lyrics without hearing them sung. The tone and message can be completely different depending on the delivery -- so apologies in advance if I've ...

    Jun 1, 2013
  • Article / Essay » General, General Re: A silly girls ramblings

    Hey Danceingtreeelf! This is, as you said in the description, very short. That's an advantage because if makes each individual sentence more important than in a novel, but it does ...

    Jun 1, 2013
  • Lyrics » Humor, Science Re: Grad School Fool

    Hey niteowl! The feel of this reminded me a lot of PhD Comics which I'm sure you'll appreciate. That is, if you don't already know about it. I think the ...

    Jun 1, 2013
  • Poetry » Dramatic, Romantic Re: Rock (18+)

    Hey jaxalexander, You've already got a decent and thorough review from magpie94 but I'll see if I can give you my impression of the poem as well. Firstly, you've got ...

    Feb 1, 2013
  • Short Story » Horror, Humor Re: Scary, Right? (18+)

    Heya dizzy, This piece made me laugh such a lot the first time I read it. I like the twist on the normal scary story -- this time it's the ...

    Feb 1, 2013
  • Short Story » Realistic, Romantic Re: El amor es... (Love is...)

    Hey Angelorchid, I'd like to talk a bit about story-psychology with regard to this piece. You write very well in that the way you form sentences and put words together ...

    Feb 1, 2013
  • Novel / Chapter » Horror, Fantasy Re: What do the dead leave? Second Draft

    Hey cm57105! I really enjoyed reading this. It's a little short in length, but you successfully cover the important points of a good beginning. You've introduced a protagonist and his ...

    Feb 1, 2013
  • Novel / Chapter » Fanfiction, Fantasy Re: Helgen

    Stori, my good man! I haven't played Skyrim, unfortunately, but I have played Oblivion and so I know a little about the Elder Scrolls games. It seems like you can ...

    Jan 31, 2013
  • Novel / Chapter » Humor, Teen Fiction Re: Yank

    Hey jon7670, I suppose I'm always drawn to pieces that have been tagged as humour because I like to see how the author has done it. For the most part ...

    Jan 30, 2013
  • Short Story » Fantasy, Humor Re: Just One More (2/2)

    Oh Stella! :D I read this (and the first part) a little while ago but I wrote some notes down so I think I should let you know even if ...

    Jan 29, 2013
  • Poetry » Dramatic, Spiritual Re: Beauty Errupts

    Hey misstoria :) I really enjoyed this poem -- it looks like niteowl has helped with some of the fine details so I'll look at the poem as a whole. ...

    Jan 7, 2013
  • Short Story » Realistic, Narrative Re: Caramel Longings

    Hey kimmybee! I giggled quite a bit at this scene. :P I think you've done well, writing this. The humour is light and not too in-your-face and the characterisation is ...

    Jan 6, 2013


maybe the backs are the stories we made along the way
— soundofmind